The Guardian Angel: from the Bible and the Church Fathers to the Third Man Phenomenon

The guardian angel in the Bible and Jewish tradition

The word "angel" derives from the Greek angelos, meaning messenger. In the Old Testament, angels appear as God's emissaries protecting specific individuals. Psalm 91 states plainly: "For he shall give his angels charge over thee, to keep thee in all thy ways." An angel also guides Tobias on a long journey, concealing his true nature until the mission is complete.

Rabbinic tradition developed this theme into a detailed system. According to it, every person has not one but two angels: a good one and an evil one. The Zohar and other kabbalistic writings describe angelic guardians as beings bound to the soul even before birth. This conviction exerted a vivid influence on everyday Jewish piety and is present to this day in bedtime prayers.

The teaching of the Church and the Church Fathers

Origen in the third century was among the first to write systematically about guardian angels. He maintained that every soul receives a guardian at the moment of coming into the world. Basil the Great and John Chrysostom developed this idea further, and Thomas Aquinas in the Summa Theologica devoted separate questions to guardian angels. According to Thomas, every human being, without exception, has an angel assigned to them from the moment of birth.

The Catholic Church celebrates the feast of the Guardian Angels on 2 October, established universally in 1670 by Pope Clement X. The Orthodox Churches have their own, similar liturgical traditions. The official teaching of the Church does not settle whether the angel leaves a person after death or continues to accompany them as a guide of the soul, which makes it a figure akin to the psychopomps present in other religions.

Guardian angels in Islam and other traditions

Islam knows the concept of kiraman katibin, the "noble scribes". The Quran describes two angels beside every person: one records good deeds, the other evil ones. The hadith tradition extends this role to protection against djinn and other harmful forces. Although Islamic angels are not identical to the Christian guardian angel, they fulfil a similar function as invisible witnesses and guardians.

The ancient Romans believed in the genius, a personal protective spirit accompanying every man throughout his life. The Greeks spoke of the daimon, as Socrates did — he heard an inner voice that restrained him from mistaken decisions. Similar conceptions of a guardian companion spirit appear in the traditions of the indigenous peoples of North America, where it is known as the "animal spirit" or "guardian spirit".

The Third Man phenomenon: science and accounts

In 1914 Ernest Shackleton recorded in his diary that during a dramatic march across the frozen Antarctic he had an overwhelming sense of the presence of a fourth person within his three-man group. Precisely the same feeling of an unknown companion was later described by Frank Smythe on Everest, Reinhold Messner on K2, and numerous aviators, castaways, and alpinists. The researcher John Geiger described the phenomenon in his 2009 book The Third Man Factor.

Scientists attempt to explain the phenomenon in several ways. The neurologist Olaf Blanke demonstrated that electrical stimulation of a specific area of the cerebral cortex produces the sensation of an invisible presence. Other researchers point to extreme stress, sleep deprivation, hypoxia, and hunger as factors that trigger hallucinations of presence. None of these hypotheses explains, however, why the unseen companion almost invariably helps and saves, and never causes harm.

The Third Man and the guardian angel: a comparison of tradition and experience

Many of those who survived an encounter with the "third man" did not hesitate to call him a guardian angel. Reinhold Messner spoke of "a friend from another dimension". Shackleton attributed the presence to Divine Providence. John Geiger noted that the accounts are strikingly consistent regardless of culture and professed religion: the stranger appears in a moment of extreme peril, points the way, and vanishes once the danger has passed.

From the perspective of Christian theology, such accounts fit readily into the role of the guardian angel as a protector in moments of mortal danger. From the perspective of science, they remain an unexplained psychological or neurological phenomenon. The two interpretations do not mutually exclude one another, and both sides acknowledge that a definitive answer does not yet exist.

The guardian angel in culture and everyday life

• The Prayer to the Guardian Angel: one of the most popular Catholic prayers, taught to children as the first after the Our Father.
• Iconography: in the art of Western Christianity the guardian angel is most commonly depicted as a winged figure leading a child across a perilous bridge.
• Name days and patronage: in Catholic tradition the guardian angel is the patron of children, travellers, and soldiers.
• New spiritualities: contemporary New Age movements have adopted the figure of the guardian angel, frequently combining it with divination and angel therapy.
• Literature and film: from Wim Wenders's Wings of Desire to Frank Capra's It's a Wonderful Life, the guardian angel is one of the most frequently recurring figures in popular culture.

Belief in the guardian angel endures not because the Church teaches it, but because it answers a profoundly human need to feel that we are not alone. Sociological surveys conducted in Western countries indicate that between 55 and 75 per cent of respondents believe in angels, often regardless of their declared religious affiliation or lack thereof.

Read more

You will find all 36 topics in the section Mysteries of life and death. All stories and books are on the pages Stories and Recommended books.

Want to ask your own question? Ask Luna or draw a card of the day.

Sources

Guardian angel, Wikipedia · Third Man factor, Wikipedia · Angelology, Wikipedia · Ernest Shackleton, Wikipedia

Frequently asked questions

Does the Bible explicitly speak of guardian angels assigned to every individual?

The Bible describes angels protecting people, but nowhere states explicitly that every person has a single assigned guardian. This conviction was developed by the Church Fathers, in particular Origen, Basil the Great, and Thomas Aquinas, who made it an element of official theology.

What exactly is the "third man" and does science explain it?

It is the phenomenon of sensing an invisible, benevolent presence in a situation of extreme danger, described by alpinists, polar explorers, and castaways. Science points to possible neurological and psychological causes, such as hypoxia or sleep deprivation, but no hypothesis has been universally accepted.

Do religions other than Christianity know the concept of the guardian angel?

Yes. Islam describes scribe angels beside every person. Judaism knows the tradition of protective angels from the Talmudic and kabbalistic writings. The ancient Greeks spoke of the daimon, the Romans of the genius, and many indigenous cultures believe in spiritual guardians in the form of animals or ancestors.